Fathering Magazine for fathers, dads, family

NOTICE: This website is FOR SALE. Buy Now!

What's New
Beginners' Tour
True Stories
True Soap

New Fathers
The Joy of Fathering
Importance of Fathers
Fathers & Sons
Fathers & Daughters
Single Fathers
Second Wives -
   Second Families
Gender & Fathers
Custody & Divorce
Father Custody
Child Support
Cyber Bullying
Sex Bullies
Family Vacation
Father's Day
Mother's Day

Book Reviews
Fathering Poems
Fathering Fiction
Cooking Recipes
Science Fair Project
US Constitution

Female Offenders
Juvenile Offenders

Child Health
New Baby
Signs of Puberty
Car Hazards
Child Obesity
Teen Smoking
Teen Drinking

Men's Health
Hair Loss
Muse ED Review

Stephen Baskerville
Michael Childers
Kirk Daulerio
John Gill
Paul Goetz
Sam Harper
Jim Loose
Mark Phillips
Fred Reed
Carey Roberts
Glenn Sacks
Clyde Verner
Archie Wortham

Child Support Policy
Child Support Math
Commercial Justice
Abuse Hysteria
Missing Child Money
Gender Equality?

Legal Disclaimer
Routine Digital Mutilation
A Short Story - Can Johnny Kramp Be Saved?

When Willie Wet the Bed
Fathering poetry about a classic problem.

Follow on

Legal Disclaimer

Home > Health - Child Circumcision > Item

Circumcision Information Network

Formerly CIN CompuBulletin
Volume 2, Number 39

NEW YORK (AP) -- A clinic has agreed to pay $1.2 ion to an 8-year-old immigrant boy who was mutilated during a botched circumcision five years ago, his lawyer said.

The settlement was reached a month after a civil trial began in state Supreme Court on allegations the boy, then 3, lost part of his penis during the operation, according to his attorney, Mark Pruzan.

The boy and his family, who asked that their names be withheld, are Russian immigrants who were referred to the Brook Plaza Surgical Ambulatory Center in Brooklyn by agencies that help new Jewish immigrants.

The clinic's attorney, Neil Ptashnik, was quoted in Wednesday's Daily News as saying that the settlement was "a business decision" that carried "specifically no admission of guilt."

The boy was one of 16 children who underwent circumcision at the Brooklyn clinic in July 1990.

The clinic, a doctor and the rabbi who performed the operation were being sued for causing "permanent shortening and disfigurement of the penis."

During the trial, experts testified that the mutilation would make sexual intercourse difficult when the boy reaches maturity, according to Wednesday's New York Post.

Under Jewish religious law, ritual circumcision -- or bris -- is performed on 8-day-old boys. But the procedure was not commonly available in the former Soviet Union. In addition, some Jewish families refrained from having their sons circumcised because it could make them targets of prejudice in communities where Jews were victims of anti-Semitism.


I am an attorney who might be having a son over the next few months and, as a result, has been seeking information on whether or not to leave him intact. Today, I came across a case in the New York Law Journal that really helped my decision. The headline read: " $1.2 Million Accord In Circumcision Suit". Why was this not in the regular press? It certainly is an "interesting" story if nothing else.

The case involved an eight-year-old boy who was circumcised by a rabbi when he was three. The rabbi who maimed this child is named Mordechai Mozes and he was uninsured and not represented at trial. Dr. Frederick Greenstein, who administered the local anesthetic; the Brook Plaza Ambulatory Surgical Center of Brooklyn, where the act was performed; and Agudath Israel of America, a third party defendant who arranged the mutilation, all contributed to the settlement. The Doctor contributed $550,000, and the other two defendants contributed $500,000 each.

Mark S. Pruzan, Esq. of Jacoby & Myers, which represented the child, stated that surgery to reattach the glans of the infant's penis was unsuccessful. The boy's name was not released.

Why was this not discussed in the media? Why was this buried deep in the Law Journal? Why were adults given the legal right to authorize this procedure on this child's body? What can be done? I think I have decided what I will do if my wife gives birth to a male in four months.

CIN: Have you contacted NOCIRC? They have loads of medical and legal information on hand (see address below). There are several lawyers working in cooperation with NOCIRC to prosecute and uphold the law, which the circumcision of minors is clearly against.

The media are, for the most part, willing accomplices in the crimes of genital mutilation. Opponents of circumcision have been largely ignored for decades. (This is why we're so active on the internet, where we are free to express our opinions.) One example is the fact that studies which suggest that circumcision has medical benefits get wide publicity, while other studies which prove them wrong are ignored. Uncovering the truth about this subject is simply too painful for most people to bear, whether they are aware of it or not.

As author Rosemary Romberg said, (I paraphrase), "The decision not to circumcise is so ridiculously simple that it hardly requires any thought."

Letter to the Editor:
American Medical News, vol. 38, no. 26 (July 17, 1995): p. 16.
Contributed by PAHadrian@aol.com

Regarding "Don't equate male circumcision with female genital mutilation" (Letters, June 5,):

Regardless of cultural milieu, genital mutilation often has the power to engage the emotions at the expense of logic and science.

The pain of circumcision is not a matter of opinion, it is a matter of scientific fact. Since 1974, over 126 studies have established that the pain of this amputative surgery is excruciating.

The opinion that nontherapeutic circumcision has valid medical applications is held exclusively by certain American physicians.

The notion that the prepuce has no defined function is incorrect, although it may serve a psychological purpose for the circumcised male.

The prepuce is a highly enervated and vascularized genital structure. It is entirely lined with the peripenic muscle sheet. Specialized ecoptic sebaceious glans on the inner preputial surface produce natural emollients and lubricants necessary for normal sexual function. The primary orgasmic triggers are found in the prepucutial orifice and frenulum. When unfolded, the prepuce is large enough to cover the length and circumference of the erect penis and acts as a natural sheath through which the shaft glides during coitus. Only the presence and functions of the prepuce allow for physiologically normal coitus to occur as designed by nature.

Males and females alike have an inherent human right to the integrity of the reproductive organs with which nature provided them.

Paul M. Fleiss, MD, MPH
Los Angeles

Frederick Hodges
Berkeley, Calif.

FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION call NOCIRC, the National Organization of Circumcision Information Resource Centers at (415) 488-9883, fax (415) 488-9660. Ask about the resource provider nearest you. For written information, write NOCIRC, PO Box 2512, San Anselmo, CA 94979, with SASE and/or donation if possible.

Copyright © 1995
FatherMag.com. All rights reserved.

The on-line magazine for men with families.

The Medical Basis for Routine Circumcision
A quest for official medical authorities of the western world that advocate child circumcision. The historical basis of the procedure.

Child Circumcision
Why was it once popular in the US? Why is it in such rapid decline today?

Protect Your Son
How a father discovered, too late, that circumcision is not a good thing.

Jews and Circumcision

The Role of Circumcision in the Islamic World
by Sami Aldeeb

Self-Test for Sexual Sensitivity
How much of your sexual sensitivity has been cut away?

Do Not Promote Circumcision for Cancer Prevention
says the American Cancer Society

Reduction Surgery
Quotes from the medical profession.

Sexual Mutilation
Quotes from internet resources.

Boy's Death Highlights New Dangers of Neonatal Circumcision
Infants experiencing circumcision are more subject to Hypovolemic Shock and Methicillin Resistant Staphyloccus Aureus (MRSA).

Horror Stories
Many live with problems resulting from involuntary circumcision.

The Circumcision Decision
Answers to your questions about infant circumcision.

Care of Intact Boys
Answers to your questions about your young son's personal care.

Listing of Publications and Organizations
Support for parents who want to protect their family from involuntary genital alteration.

Glossary of Related Terms

Non-surgical foreskin restoration.

External links:
Circumcision Decision Maker
Avoid a circumcision mistake! Learn more about this permanent decision.

Anatomy and Mechanics of Intercourse
The physical function of the foreskin.
by Geoffrey T. Falk