Your Father, Why Bother
How daughters can strengthen relationships with their fathers
by Dr. Linda Nielsen
© ArtToday. All rights reserved.
Even though you and
your father love one another and get along well most of the time, do
you usually talk more openly about personal things and spend more
time alone with your mother? And if you have a daughter, do you and
she spend more time together and talk about more personal things than
she and her father do? If you're like most women in our country,
your answer is yes.
So what? Your father,
why bother? As a daughter why bother creating a more personal or more
involved relationship with your father -- especially if you are
already a married woman or a mother? And if you are a mother, why
bother teaching your daughter how to create a more meaningful, more
communicative relationship with her dad? Even as a member or the
leader of a church, why bother helping daughters and fathers create
more meaningful relationships?
Because - regardless
of their age, daughters who have meaningful, comfortable
relationships with their fathers are generally more self-confident
and independent, have better relationships with men, are less
depressed, have fewer eating disorders and drug or alcohol problems
and achieve more in school and at work. And the easier it is for a
daughter to communicate with her father, the more she enjoys being
with him and the more she gets out of their relationship.
So how do we help
ourselves and our daughters embrace father-daughter relationships
Step One: Stop discriminating against your father
When I ask
daughters why they don't know their fathers as well as they know
their mothers or why they don't share as much with their fathers
most say: "Because he's man, he doesn't want to talk about
serious or personal things with me."
"Because fathers and daughters aren't supposed to know each other or be open the way
mothers and daughters are." Sound familiar? If so, use this quiz to
see whether you are denying your father the opportunities to create a
more meaningful relationship with you.
Use 0 for "never," 1 for "rarely," 2 for "usually" and 3
for "almost always."
- ___ I spend as much time alone with my father as I spend
alone with my mother.
- ___ I talk directly to my dad instead of going through other people
to communicate with him.
- ___ I go to my father for advice and for comfort about personal
- ___ I ask my father as many meaningful questions about his life, his
feelings and his ideas as I ask my mother.
- ___ I share important parts of my life as much with my father as with
- ___ I make as much effort to get to know my father as I do with my
- ___ I encourage my father to ask me questions about my life rather
than acting as if he is prying or interfering when he does ask.
- ___ I am as open and honest with my dad as I am with my mom.
- ___ I invite my father to do things alone with me so that we have
time to talk privately.
- ___ I show my father that I appreciate his skills as a parent,
especially when he does things differently than my mother does them.
- ___ I let my father know that he has had and still does have as much
impact on my life as my mother does.
- ___ Your score (30 possible)
The higher your score, the easier you have made it for your father to
develop a meaningful, loving, comfortable, fulfilling relationship
with you -- and the less you have discriminated against him. The
lower your score, the more you will benefit by starting to do the
things listed in the quiz.
Step Two: Spend More Time Alone with Dad
The single most important thing you can do to strengthen your
relationship is to spend more time alone with your dad and to use
this time alone to ask him more meaningful questions. This sounds
simple enough. Daughters repeatedly tell me about the remarkable
changes that come over their fathers when they talk to him without
anyone else around. If this idea makes you uncomfortable, try easing
into it by inviting your father to do these sorts of things with you:
(1) Show you how to do something that he enjoys or does
well--something as simple as trimming plants, grilling steaks his
special way, or playing a card game. (2) Go to a religious service
alone with you. (3) Tag along with him for a few hours while he does
errands. (4) Go to a movie together -share a box of popcorn. (5)
Take you back to the neighborhood where he grew up and walk around
together. (6) Ask him to choose 15 or 20 of his favorite photographs
from various times of his life and as he's telling you about them,
say things to relax and open him up, such as: "Tell me more about
that. What was that like? Why did that happen? How did that make you
feel at the time? What else was going on in your life at that time?
What happened next? How do you feel about that now?" Remember:
nobody else should be around while you're doing this.
Step Three: Ask Your "Lion" More Meaningful Questions
fable about a little girl who asks, "How can Tarzan have been so
smart, so strong, and so magnificent that without help from anyone at
all he defeated every one of the jungle animals, including the mighty
lions." The listener replied, "Child, you'll get a different
story if the lion learns to talk." In the same way, you need to
learn to speak directly to your father to get his feelings and his
views of things.
since half of our fathers die before we reach the age of fifty, it is
time to start asking your
"lion" more personal questions like these: (1)Who was your
favorite relative and why? (2) What are some of your favorite
childhood memories? (3) What did you get too little of and too much
of from your father? (4) Other than relatives, who had the greatest
influence on you as a child and as a teenager? (5) If you had a
motto, what would it be? (6) What would bring you the greatest joy
during the next few years? (7) What is the best and the worst advice
a friend ever gave you? (8) How have your spiritual beliefs changed
over time and who has influenced you the most? (9) If you could have
any two spiritual questions answered, what would they be? (10)What
are three of the best and three of the worst decisions you've ever
made? (11) What are some lessons you had to learn the hard way? (12)
What are some of the most important things you've learned about
love and marriage? (13) How did your relationship with your dad
influence the kind of parent you have been? (14) What was the best
gift and best compliment I ever gave you? (15) How has our
relationship changed over the years?
If you take
these, will it be worth it? After following my advice, here's a
small sample of what daughters have to say: Nancy: "Until I
started asking my father personal questions and spending time alone
with him, I had no idea what a spiritual person he was. I have so
much to learn from him." Beth: "My dad and I are finally
able to talk about my mother's death. It has been a healing,
comforting bond for us." Sue : "I had never seen
pictures of him as a child"so small and vulnerable. When I got him
talking about his dad, I saw him trying not to cry. I reached over
to him and said it was okay to talk to me about it. It was the first
time I had ever comforted my father." Lynne: "As I
listened to him, I began to see my father as a person who struggles
through life as a man and a husband"not just as my parent. It meant
so much to have him open up to me." Trish: "Even at my
age, I could never imagine talking to my father about personal
things. But now I'm relating to him as someone other than an
extension of my mother." Amy:
"I'm glad I realized before it's too late that my father isn't
just a bald guy who always has his head stuck in a book. I have so
much to learn from him." Marty: "Now I realize he
and I have been wanting the same thing from our relationship all
these years. But we had never talked enough to figure that out."
Anna: "I cried when my father said the best gift I have ever
given him is deciding that - finally - I want to get to know him.
He got this sweet look on his face, gave a big sigh and said, "I
was really nervous about answering some of your questions. I mean, we
have never really talked or spent time alone like this before now."
By embracing your relationship with your father more fully - and by
helping your daughter do the same - you embrace the best in your
Embracing Your Father: How to Build the Relationship You Always Wanted with Your Dad
Nielsen is the author of EMBRACING YOUR FATHER:
How to Create the Relationship You Want with Your Dad
(McGraw Hill, 2004). She is a professor at Wake Forest
University and author of two books on adolescent psychology. Having
worked with adolescent and adult daughters for over 30 years, since
1990 she has been teaching the only college course in the country
devoted exclusively to father-daughter relationships. Through her
course, radio and television interviews, and articles in popular
magazines, Dr. Nielsen helps daughters strengthen or reestablish
their relationships with their fathers -- especially daughters whose
parents are divorced. The recipient of several awards for her
research and writing, she also serves as a resource for fathers,
daughters, and practitioners through her web site: www.wfu.edu/~nielsen.
Copyright © 2004
FatherMag.com. All rights reserved.
FatherMag.com authors retain their right to republish elsewhere.